How Churches and Charities Should Handle Disciplinary Issues
Perfect Grace HR | HR Guidance for Christian Organisations
Quick Answer
How should a charity handle a disciplinary issue?
Charities should follow the ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance Procedures. This involves a thorough investigation, a formal hearing, the right to be accompanied, a decision with reasons, and the right of appeal.
Why Disciplinary Processes Matter
Even in mission-driven organisations, conduct or performance issues arise. Handling them fairly and consistently protects both the employee and the organisation. Failure to follow a fair process — even where the underlying reason for dismissal is valid — can result in costly employment tribunal claims.
Step 1 — Investigation
Before taking any formal action, carry out a reasonable investigation to establish the facts. This may include reviewing evidence, speaking to witnesses and giving the employee the opportunity to explain their perspective. The investigation should be carried out by someone who is not involved in the allegation.
Step 2 — Formal Hearing
If the investigation identifies potential misconduct, invite the employee to a formal disciplinary hearing in writing, with reasonable notice. The letter should explain the allegations and include copies of relevant evidence. The employee has the right to be accompanied by a colleague or trade union representative.
Step 3 — Decision
After the hearing, inform the employee of the outcome in writing. Possible outcomes include no action, a first written warning, a final written warning or dismissal. The decision should be proportionate to the seriousness of the issue.
Step 4 — Right of Appeal
Employees must be given the right to appeal the decision. The appeal should be heard by someone not previously involved in the case where possible.
Gross Misconduct
Some conduct is sufficiently serious to justify summary dismissal — dismissal without notice. Examples include theft, violence, serious harassment or a fundamental breach of trust. Even in gross misconduct cases, a fair investigation and hearing process must still be followed before dismissal.
Faith Considerations
Christian organisations sometimes face situations where conduct relates to an employee's personal life or beliefs. These cases require particularly careful handling to avoid discrimination claims. Perfect Grace HR can advise on the correct approach for complex or sensitive disciplinary situations.